Researchers have identified several new enzymes capable of attacking two widely used types of plastic, polyurethane and nylon, for which there are currently virtually no viable recycling options. The enzymes, found in bacteria from sources including a tropical zoo and a landfill site in Kenya, are the first reported to break down even long, insoluble plastic chains and cross-linked forms of polyurethane.
Plastic is designed to last, which is precisely why some of it is almost impossible to recycle.
But things may look very different in the future, now that researchers have discovered a range of new enzymes that can begin to take apart two of the most widespread and stubborn types of plastic: polyurethane and nylon.
The enzymes come from bacteria collected from places where microorganisms have long lived side by side with plastic.
The hope is to use them to break the plastic back down into smaller building blocks, thereby enabling materials that currently end up largely as waste can be used to make new materials.
“At the moment, it is virtually impossible to break down these types of plastic in an economically viable way. But if we can find a technology that can do this at relatively low temperature and pressure, so that we do not have to spend a lot of money heating the reaction, we can start recycling the materials and giving the waste a value,” says a researcher behind the study, Malthe Kjær Bendtsen, PhD student at the EnZync research centre at Aarhus University in Denmark.
The research has been published in Angewandte Chemie International Edition.
The hunt for enzymes led to a zoo and a landfill
Polyurethane is present in foam mattresses, insulation and paint, and nylon is familiar from fishing nets and tights. Both consist of long chains that are difficult to break apart again, and polyurethane in particular can be bound together in a dense network. As a result, no industrial-scale solution can effectively recycle these materials yet. They typically end up in landfill or are incinerated.
In nature, enzymes already exist that can attack some of the chemical bonds found in plastic. The researchers therefore went looking for them in places where plastic and microorganisms had lived side by side for the longest time. They looked for warm, damp environments in which bacteria had had plenty of time to encounter polyurethane and nylon.
The idea was that bacteria living on the plastic might have enzymes with other functions that, by chance, could also cut some of plastic’s chemical bonds. That ability could give the bacteria a slight advantage in such environments.
The samples came from Randers Regnskov Tropical Zoo in western Denmark, where much of the interior has been made of plastic for the past 30 years, from compost heaps and from the guts of wax-worm larvae that had been fed polyurethane foam. A microbiologist from the group also travelled to Kenya to search landfill sites.
“If we look back at history, it is only about 100 years since we invented the first plastic, and polyurethane is even younger. On an evolutionary time scale, that is a split second. So we were looking for broad-spectrum enzymes that can do a bit of everything. They did not necessarily evolve to break down plastic, but if they happen to be able to cleave some of the same chemical bonds, that might give the bacterium a slight advantage,” says Malthe Kjær Bendtsen.
They searched for what the enzymes could do – not what they looked like
Normally, the search for new plastic-degrading enzymes involves looking for proteins that resemble ones we already know. The researchers did the opposite. Together with the Danish Technological Institute, they developed fluorescent molecules that act as tiny spies.
These mimic one of the chemical bonds in the plastic, and if a bacterium has an enzyme that can cleave it, the molecule changes its fluorescent signal. This enabled the researchers to sort thousands of bacteria per second and pick out those that lit up. Thus, they sorted them according to what the bacteria could do and not what their enzymes looked like.
They then broke open the bacteria and separated the proteins through several rounds of purification while tracking which samples could still cleave the bond. In the end, they identified 29 different bacteria and 12 enzymes – 10 targeting polyurethane and two targeting nylon.
“There are perhaps 5,000 genes in a bacterium like this, and only one is responsible for producing the enzyme. The difficult part is therefore identifying that specific gene. Eventually, we cloned the gene into an Escherichia coli bacterium that could not break down our plastic molecule on its own, and when it could do so afterwards, we had proof that the enzyme was responsible,” explains Malthe Kjær Bendtsen.
The enzymes also work on real plastic
Several of the enzymes bear only a limited resemblance to those previously described. But the fluorescent test was only the first test. The crucial question was whether they could also break the bonds in long, solid plastic chains.
They could. The enzymes released degradation products from both insoluble nylon and long chains of polyurethane – including the cross-linked form, in which the chains are joined in a three-dimensional network, as in mattress foam. This type of plastic has so far been among the most difficult for enzymes to deal with.
There is still a long way to go, however, before this becomes a usable technology. Over three days, the most active enzyme broke down just under 1% of the polyurethane in the mattress foam.
By comparison, PET-degrading enzymes have been optimised over years of development to break down virtually the entire material in a single day, and the technology is already being put to industrial use.
Now the enzymes need sharpening
The modest figures do not surprise Malthe Kjær Bendtsen.
“This is a very new field, and you should not imagine that, any time soon, you can simply put your old mattress in a tub of enzymes and watch it disappear. But this is a starting-point. The enzymes probably did not evolve to break down plastic at all, yet they can still do it. So nature has already given us some starting-points on which we can build,” he says.
The next step is therefore to use the enzymes they have found as rough models and modify them so that they cut faster, tolerate higher temperatures and remain active for longer. The aim is to reach high double-digit percentages, which the researchers would consider groundbreaking.
One dream is that a mattress factory might one day be able to feed its waste back into production simply by adding an enzyme – turning the waste back into raw material.
“The good thing about this material is that, at the moment, there is no value in recycling it, so anything better than nothing is a gain. We would very much like this to become a technology that industry can use to give these types of plastic a new life. There are still many open questions, but we are working on how best to bring the enzymes into contact with the material so that we can reach those high percentages,” concludes Malthe Kjær Bendtsen.
